New York City is consistently celebrated as one of the greatest places to live for singles. But big city life—and prices—are not for everyone. Even before the pandemic, young professionals were steering clear of the crowds, chaos, and cost of living in New York City and choosing to find their personal bliss on Long Island.


Beyond the five, well-known boroughs are some under-the-radar gems, offering proximity to the big apple’s madness, and chiller vibes. This will give you some insight into some of the best places to live on Long Island.

1.   Great Neck Gardens. NY

Ranked the number one neighborhood to live in the state on Niche’s 2021 Best Places to Live list, Great Neck Gardens has a suburban feel with many homes from different periods and well-preserved neighborhood history. Currently, the median home value in Great Neck Gardens is $1.2M.

2.   Jericho, NY

Located on Long Island’s Northern Shore, Jericho is a hamlet and a CDP in Nassau County. Niche named it the second-best neighborhood in the state, and it is easy to understand why. The village of Jericho is less than 30 miles from central Manhattan, has easy access to the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), and is home to some of the top schools in New York. Furthermore, the median home value in the area is around $967,500, making it relatively affordable.

3.   Holtsville, NY

For those limiting their search to the more affordable Long Island neighborhoods, then Holtsville requires your attention. The average median home value is $495,000—though it usually sits under the $400K range. In addition to the price, this neighborhood located in the town of Islip offers outdoor entertainment and recreational activities for its residents, in addition to wildlife education from the Wildlife and Ecology Center.

4.   Valley Stream, NY

Not only is Valley Stream affordable—with a median home value of $630,000—it is commuter-friendly with its own LRR station while also being nestled right next to Queens county. Though it is easy to be in the city in the blink of an eye, many locals choose to stay nearby during the weekends, as Valley Stream has affordable dining options and leisure activities.

5.   Long Beach, NY

The list of Long Island neighborhoods would be incomplete without mentioning Long Beach-and no, we are not talking about the one in California. The Long Beach, NY community is located just 40 minutes from Manhattan in Nassau County and is perfect for small NYC businesses, entrepreneurs, and freelancers looking for a more beachy atmosphere. The beaches, surf shops, nightlife, and over two miles of boardwalk in Long Beach are sure to draw them in. Plus, the median house value in Long Beach is only $720,000, so you can find the perfect home within your budget.





No matter what Long Island neighborhood you decide to call home, working with a good mortgage lender is important. That is why Lynx Mortgage Bank LLC is with you every step of the way. With guided customer care and our team of first-time home buying mortgage experts, you can breathe a sigh of relief. Contact us today to receive expert mortgage advice from one of our team members.

Skip to content